Fracture


In past studies, in collaboration with Benoit Roman, we have addressed the extremely robust patterns that emerge in the fracture of thin brittle sheets both in the context of cutting by a blunt object and tearing. We have shown that this robustness of the obtained fracture patterns results from the prominent role of geometry in the processes. For example, we have analyzed the triangular shapes formed when tearing a thin adhesive sheet from a solid substrate. An everyday example of this process is the annoying triangular piece that one ends up with when unsuccessfully trying to peel tape from a roll of scotch-tape. In collaboration with Markus Buehler (MIT) and Kostya Novoselov (Manchester), we have demonstrated that similar fracture patterns can also be found when tearing graphene sheets.


Fracture Toughness through Scratching

with: Ange-Therese Akono and Franz Ulm




We present results of a hybrid experimental and theoretical investigation of the fracture scaling in scratch tests and show that scratching is a fracture dominated process. Validated for paraffin wax, cement paste, Jurassic limestone and steel, we derive a model that provides a quantitative means to relate quantities measured in scratch tests to fracture properties of materials at multiple scales. The scalability of scratching for different probes and depths opens new venues towards miniaturization of our technique, to extract fracture properties of materials at even smaller length scales.

Video of the scratching experiments on paraffin: [Movie]

Publications:
• A-T. Akono, P.M. Reis, and F-J. Ulm “Scratching as a Fracture Process: From Butter to Steel” Phys. Rev. Lett, 106 204302 (2011) [html, pdf]. (Physical Review Focus)

Press Coverage:
• “Scratching Reaches the Breaking Point” Physical Review Focus 27, May 20th, 2011.
• “Researchers redefine the old ‘scratch test’” MITnews, June 2nd, 2011.


Tearing of thin adhesive sheets

with: Benoit Roman, Enrique Cerda, and Eugenio Hamm




Thin adhesive films have become increasingly important in applications involving packaging, coating or for advertising. Once a film is adhered to a substrate, flaps can be detached by tearing and peeling, but they narrow and collapse in pointy shapes. Similar geometries are observed when peeling ultrathin films grown or deposited on a solid substrate, or skinning the natural protective cover of a ripe fruit. In this work, we have shown that the detached flaps have perfect triangular shapes with a well-defined vertex angle; this is a signature of the conversion of bending energy into surface energy of fracture and adhesion.In particular, this triangular shape of the tear encodes the mechanical parameters related to these three forms of energy and could form the basis of a quantitative assay for the mechanical characterization of thin adhesive films, nanofilms deposited on substrates or fruit skin.

Publications:
• E. Hamm, P.M. Reis, M. LeBlanc, B. Roman and E. Cerda, “Tearing as a test for mechanical characterization of thin adhesive films”, Nature Materials, 96, 386 (2008), [html,pdf] Supplementary Material [html, pdf], Front Cover [html, pdf], [Video].

Press Coverage:
• “Material mechanics: An angle on sticky films”, J. Groenewold, News and Views, Nature Materials 7 348 (2008). [html, pdf];
• “A Sticky Issue”, D. Castelvecchi, Science News 173 12 (2008). [html];
• Audio coverage of our article on tearing of adhesive sheet [A16]: Interview for NPR’s (USA) “Morning Edition” (April 2, 2008) [Listen]. Interview of B. Roman for RTL’s (France) “Le Journal de 7h” (April 29, 2008) [Listen]. Interview of B. Roman for RSR’s (Switzerland) “La Science de Pain” (May 26, 2008) [Listen]. Scientific American 60-Second Science Podcast [Listen]. • International press coverage of our article on tearing of adhesive sheet [A16]:
• MIT TechTalk (USA); MIT News Office Press Release (USA); El Mercurio (Chile); USACH Al Día (Chile); The Globe and Mail (Canada); Malaysia Sun (Malazya); Daily India (India); Ciência Hoje (Portugal); deFrente Algébrica (Portugal); KIJK (Holland); Publico (Spain); NyTeknik (Sweden); Pour la Science (France); Science et Avenir (France); Le figaro (France); La Croix (France); CNRS Press Release (France); Le Matin (Switzerland); GEO [pdf] (Germany);
• Online press coverage of our article on tearing of adhesive sheet [A16]: MIT Homepage, CNN, MSNBC, NanoWerk, Science Daily, Eurekalert, Physorg, Yahoo News, Live Science, Ars Technica, Inovations-Report, Science News Daily.


Tearing of Graphene Sheets

with: Dipanjan Sen, Kostya Novoselov and Markus Buehler




Graphene is a truly two-dimensional atomic crystal with exceptional electronic and mechanical properties. Whereas conventional bulk and thin-film materials have been studied extensively, the key mechanical properties of graphene, such as tearing and cracking, remain unknown, partly due to its two-dimensional nature and ultimate single-atom-layer thickness, which result in the breakdown of conventional material models. By combining first-principles ReaxFF molecular dynamics and experimental studies, a bottom-up investigation of the tearing of graphene sheets from adhesive substrates is reported, including the discovery of the formation of tapered graphene nanoribbons. Through a careful analysis of the underlying molecular rupture mechanisms, it is shown that the resulting nanoribbon geometry is controlled by both the graphene-substrate adhesion energy and by the number of torn graphene layers. By considering graphene as a model material for a broader class of two-dimensional atomic crystals, these results provide fundamental insights into the tearing and cracking mechanisms of highly confined nanomaterials.

Publications:
• D. Sen, K. Novoselov, P. M. Reis and M.J. Buehler, “Tearing of graphene sheets from adhesive substrates produces tapered nanoribbons”, Small 6 1108 (2010). [html, pdf] Supplementary Info [html, pdf].

Press Coverage:
• Collaborating teams apply findings developed at macroscale to materials at atomistic scale. CEE Newsletter “On Balance” (July 2010) [pdf].


Oscillatory Fracture in Thin Sheets

with: Benoit Roman, Basile Audoly, Anil Kumar, Mark Shattuck and Simon de Villiers




Opening the plastic packaging film of biscuit packs or CD cases has never been easy, specially if one lacks a pen-knife in our pocket. One way out is to use a key or a pen. If we use such a blunter object to tear open the plastic, rather than observing a straight cut, the crack follows a well defined and highly reproducible oscillatory path. We have developed a well controlled experiment in which to study this phenomena. Moreover, we have developed a geometrical 2D model that takes into account bending and stretching of the thing plastic film. This simplemodel yields results in excellent agreement with the experiments.


For more info and videos of the experiment please visit this webpage.

Publications:
• P.M. Reis, A. Kumar, M.D. Shattuck and B. Roman, “Unzip Instabilities: straight to oscillatory transitions in the cutting of thin elastic sheets”, Europhys. Lett. 82, 64002 (2008). [html,pdf]
• P.M. Reis, B. Roman and B. Audoly “Oscillating fracture paths in thin elastic sheets: when geometry rules the fracture path”, Proceedings of the 16th European Conference on Fracture, Alexandroupolis, Greece, “Fracture of Nano and Engineering Materials and Structures”, page 119 (Springer 2006). [pdf]
• B. Audoly, B. Roman and P.M. Reis, “Cracks in Brittle thin Sheets: When Geometry Rules the Fracture Path”, Phys. Rev. Lett. 95, 025502 (2005). [html, pdf];
• B. Audoly, B. Roman and P.M. Reis, “Comment on The Cycloidal Wake of a cylinder Tearing Through a Thin Sheet”, Phys, Rev. Lett. 94, 129601 (2005). [html, pdf];
• B. Roman, P.M. Reis, B. Audoly, S. de Villiers, V. Vignie and D. Vallet, “Oscillatory fracture paths in thin elastic sheets”, C.R. de Mecanique 331, 881 (2003). [html, pdf]

Press Coverage:
• “Crumpling, buckling, and cracking: Elasticity of thin sheets”, M. Marder, R. D. Deegan and E. Sharon, Physics Today 60 (2), 33 , February (2007). [html, pdf];
• “Cracked it”, Research Highlights; Nature 436, 306 (2005). [pdf] • “Envelope physics sheds light on ice sheets”, Nature Science Update, 02 Dec (2003).